SmarTech Publishing Research Note: New Guide to Metal AM Examines Rise of the “Additive Factory”

SmarTech Publishing’s The Production Manager’s Guide to 3D Printing with Metals, analyzes several key aspects to consider when implementing metal AM in a company’s workflow. One particularly interesting development that production managers will need to consider is the rise of the Additive Factory.  We think that this would bring significant benefits in several industrial areas, especially for round-the-clock manufacturing of parts and components for the automotive and aerospace.

Guide metal AM Examines

Concept Laser’s vision of the factory of tomorrow puts modular 3D printers together with other modules dedicated to automated process and post-process management
Credits: Concept Laser

We think that the additive factory is both imminent and will exercise a profound effect production dynamics.

Building the Additive Factory 

In our Guide to Metal 3D Printing with Metals, we have identified several elements that suggest Additive Factories will become common over the next decade and are something that production managers should be thinking about now.

# 1.  Additive Factories already exist. The first additive factories have already been established by GE (Avio Aero in Italy and its plant in Japan with Matsuura technology). Other product agnostic centers with over 20 metal systems for short series production are being built by Lazer Zentrum Nord (Bionic Production) and Citim in Germany.
# 2.  Production rates and size capabilities are constantly increasing for all manufacturers. All metal 3D printer manufacturers are eyeing increased productivity and are taking different approaches towards it. Arcam is speeding up production by enabling more powder to come in contact with the electron beam; SLM Solutions already offers a 4 laser system, while EOS has just introduced the new 4 laser version of its EOSINT M400. Concept Laser will also offer a four laser system and has recently introduced the XLine 2000, the largest metal powder bed fusion 3D printer on the market.
# 3. More automated systems are being developed. Metal 3D printer manufacturers are investing considerably in process automation. Concept Laser presents the concept for a fully automated modular factor based on its next generation of 3D printers. Additive Industries has developed a fully automated system capable of 10X production cycles for its vision of “lights off factories”. Renishaw has introduced its idea for an automated process that begins from additive manufacturing of a part that then undergoes further post processing through automated measurement and finishing stations.
# 4.  Additively Manufactured parts are now over 99% dense. Additively manufactured metal parts are now, at 99% density or above, mechanically equal or even superior to parts produced by metal die casting. This is true for SLM technologies and even more so for EBM, which can achieve part as dense as 99.9% and above.

What can the Additive Factory do for Production Needs?

Metal additive manufacturing can be used today for short series production of small, highly complex, end-use, functional parts and components. All currently available major metal 3D printing processes (binder jetting, powder bed fusion and directed energy deposition) can be used to this end, however, each technology offers specific advantages and limitations.  In the Exhibit below, we show which additive manufacturing technologies are most appropriate for low volume production – and therefore are most likely to be used in an Additive Factory.

Guide metal AM Examines

Credits: SmarTech Publishing

The single biggest advantage of using metal AM is the technology’s capability for production of topologically optimized “bionic” structures. These are highly complex shapes, such as trabecular, lattice or fractal structures, which are generatively designed through CAD software. These highly complex shapes can only be reproduced physically through additive manufacturing’s unique geometrical freedom. In fact, in most cases, the more complex a part’s geometry is, the easier that part will be to 3D print. Since AM does not require a mold or a CNC machine tool to reach into the cavities, it can produce the parts, which are designed by CAD calculations and parametric settings, to be up to 90% lighter, without a loss in structural integrity.

Within the additive factory of tomorrow, SmarTech Publishing believes that the most common technology for short series production will remain powder bed fusion. This type of process includes electron beam powder bed fusion (EBM), offered uniquely by Swedish metal 3D printer manufacturer Arcam (currently being acquired by GE), and laser powder bed fusion, generically known as selective laser melting (SLM), which is offered by several system manufacturers.

EBM is ideal for production as it can be used to print stacked parts, thus increasing the production rate. On the other hand, there are many more laser powder bed fusion manufacturers and their combined technologies can already use a wider (virtually limitless) selection of metals. SLM can also be used for short series production, especially in larger size 3D printers. In order to maximize production rates, several SLM 3D printer manufacturers are offering both larger machines and multiple lasers (South Africa based Aerosud’s upcoming system is believed to be able to print parts as wide as two meters). To be exploited to the fullest, higher production rates will require a fully automated process for powder management, build chamber atmosphere control, process management, part cooling and post processing. The promise is that of highly efficient, round the clock, fully digital production of short series, destined to become exponentially larger over time.

About SmarTech Publishing’s 3D Printing with Metals End-User Report

This is a practical guide for the production manager who wants to get up to speed on the state of the art in metals-based additive manufacturing and where it is headed in the future.  It is focused specifically on the requirements and practical aspects of implementing metals printing including providing direction on equipment choice, process integration and materials selection.  This Guide answers important questions such as:

  • Which are the technologies that you should implement?
  • Which materials should you use to obtain optimal price/speed/quality ratios?
  • Should you use metal 3D printing just for functional prototyping or for short-run production?
  • What are the characteristics that make a particular product fit to be 3D printed in metal?
  • Which prototypes, tools and parts can already be 3D printed?

The reader of this Guide will discover what each metal AM technology can offer in terms of size, speed, costs, production capabilities and automation. It analyzes each of the most commonly used materials to expose advantages and challenges in their utilization. Finally, it explores both the dominant current and near future applications in which metal AM can offer unrivaled manufacturing advantages.

If interested in purchasing a copy of this report, please email missy@smartechpublishing.com or you can purchase it directly on SmarTech Publishing’s website.

About SmarTech Publishing

SmarTech Publishing has published reports on most of the important revenue opportunities in the 3D printing sector including personal printers, low-volume manufacturing, 3D printing materials, medical/dental applications, aerospace and other promising 3D market segments.  Our client roster includes some of the largest 3D printer firms, materials firms and investors in the world.

Since 2014, SmarTech Publishing has published dedicated, in-depth market studies focused on additive manufacturing opportunities in the metals sector.

Press Contact:
Lawrence Gasman
lawrence@smartechpublishing.com
434-872-0450

SmarTech Publishing Research Note: Nickel Alloys to Grow at Faster Pace than Titanium, Cobalt Chrome and Stainless Steel through 2020

In SmarTech Publishing’s latest ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING WITH METAL POWDERS 2016: AN OPPORTUNITY ANALYSIS AND TEN-YEAR FORECAST report, we predict that the use of nickel alloys will grow at a faster pace than titanium, cobalt chrome, and stainless steel for the next five years. This is primarily due to to a wealth of recent applications stemming from use in aerospace, energy, and even medical applications using the popular super alloys Inconel, which are currently available for additive manufacturing in 718, 625, and 939 formulations.

New Nickel Alloy Applications in AM

SmarTech Publishing has identified several factors that suggest increased nickel alloys adoption across a variety of manufacturing segments

# 1.  Increased adoption by aerospace sector expected. The aerospace industry is utilizing AM processes with nickel alloys in a number of high-value areas. These span the entirety of the aerospace industry, from commercial craft, to military, and even into space. Inconel has been the alloy of choice for various printed combustion chamber elements in space launch vehicles tested by NASA, Aerojet Rocketdyne, Space-X, and more.

# 2.  New specialty surgical tools using Inconel. Surgical tools have recently been 3D printed in Inconel representing an interesting expansion of application for nickel alloys in AM. DanaMed created its Pathfinder ACL Guide that has been called a game changer for ACL surgical repair, and has significantly increased success rates associated with the procedure while reducing the incidence of re-tear.

# 3.  Adoption by Arcam for EBM, production by AP&C. The only manufacturer of electron beam melting AM systems, Arcam (just acquired by GE), has recently introduced support for nickel alloys in its systems. AP&C, a subsidiary of Arcam, already produces nickel alloys utilizing its plasma atomization technology. Although the company focuses a significant amount of production on titanium alloys, its nickel alloy output has increased in recent years. Meanwhile, almost every major provider of metal powders utilizing gas atomization is now also providing nickel alloys for additive manufacturing.

# 4.  Highest revenue generating alloy in automotive. Nickel is expected to become the most used alloy for AM in the automotive sector, growing alongside and often surpassing stainless steel to reach 452 tons used yearly in 2025 (vs 443 tons for stainless steel). At the same time it is expected to remain significantly more costly per kilogram than stainless steels, thus generating significantly more revenues than any other metal powder used in the automotive sector.

Nickel Alloys to Grow at Faster Pace than Titanium

Revenues generated by nickel alloys in AM processes within the automotive sector are expected to remain higher than those generated by stainless steel, which is the other most used metal material in automotive.

Nickel Superalloys Will Shape the Future of AM

Nickel superalloys are utilized with all metal AM printing technologies (including binder jetting, electron beam powder bed fusion, and most commonly laser-based powder bed fusion and powder directed energy deposition): Nickel alloys are some of the most widely used metal powders in additive manufacturing today for a variety of high performance components, in both the area of functioning prototypes and true end-use components.

Today, the most popular by far are the Inconel superalloys, which are an exclusive trademark of the Special Metals Group and are currently available for additive manufacturing primarily in 718, 625 (and the less common) 939 formulations. Additional nickel alloys capable of being printed today include Hastalloy-X, a nickel-chromium-iron-molybdenum alloy that offers oxidation and high temperature resistance, high manufacturability and high resistance to stress-corrosion cracking in petrochemical applications.

These characteristics are also present in the more popular Inconel 718 and Iconel 625 powders for AM. These are also a high-strength, corrosion-resistant nickel chromium alloys (with the addition of molybdenum in 625).

Inconel 718 is known to retain its properties at temperatures ranging from -423°F to 1300°F. The ease and economy with which it can be fabricated (one Kg of powder costs about $200), combined with good tensile, fatigue, creep, and rupture strength, have resulted in its use in a wide range of applications. Inconel 625 is used for high strength, excellent manufacturability and corrosion resistance. Service temperatures range from cryogenic to 1800°F (982°C).

Possible applications for these nickel alloys span nearly the entire spectrum of additive manufacturing, from toolmaking to high functionality test parts, to one hundred percent end-use parts in critical applications — especially aerospace and defense markets. This is because Nickel alloys are highly valued for their significant heat resistant and corrosion resistant properties, along with good mechanical characteristics in tensile strength and endurance. For modern aircraft engines, roughly 50 percent of weight is typically from nickel alloy parts, making these alloys that much easier to transition to from an industry acceptance perspective.

About the Report:

SmarTech Publishing believes that these – combined with other elements relative to the general market for materials which are explored in Additive Manufacturing with Metal Powders 2016: An Opportunity Analysis and Ten-Year Forecast – will contribute to nickel’s establishment as one of the primary materials for AM and thus offer a significant opportunity to explore for the near to medium term future.

This report is the most comprehensive market study of metal additive manufacturing ever created, including analysis of

  • Opportunities for metal powder suppliers
  • The evolution of metal powder supply chains to meet the needs of evolving additive manufacturing markets
  • Existing and emerging metal additive manufacturing technologies
  • Metal-oriented 3D printing services
  • End user industries and applications that are adopting metal printing

In this report, SmarTech Publishing presents a complete analysis of the powder manufacturing supply chain.  No other source provides such a wealth of analysis and market data on metal additive manufacturing.

SmarTech Publishing’s industry-standard ten-year forecasts are applied in this report across the entire metal additive manufacturing sector – from print technology and install bases, to powder demand by adopting industry, to revenues associated with metal additive manufacturing materials.

If interested in receiving a quote or purchasing this report, please email missy@smartechpublishing.com.

Please also see our report 3D-Printed Metals:  A Patent Landscape Analysis – 2016.

About SmarTech Publishing

SmarTech Publishing has published reports on most of the important revenue opportunities in the 3D printing sector including personal printers, low-volume manufacturing, 3D printing materials, medical/dental applications, aerospace and other promising 3D market segments.  Our client roster includes some of the largest 3D printer firms, materials firms and investors in the world.

Since 2014, SmarTech Publishing has published dedicated, in-depth market studies focused on additive manufacturing opportunities in the metals sector.

Contact:
Lawrence Gasman
lawrence@smartechpublishing.com
434-872-0450